10–4: never in the Premier League, once before it
In 13,266 matches since August 1992, the Premier League has never seen 10–4. The old First Division saw it once, Tottenham 10–4 Everton in 1958. If it happens again, @footygami will post it at full time.
No team has ever scored 10 goals in a Premier League match. The most is 9.
10–4 before the Premier League
The old First Division (1888/89 to 1991/92) saw it once: Tottenham 10–4 Everton on October 11, 1958.